Graph: St. Louis Cardinals: WAR by Acquisition Type (1995-2013)

While working on a separate project, I recently compiled a lot of data about my beloved St. Louis Cardinals and the value provided to their roster by individual players. My other project focuses on the Cardinals in the Walt Jocketty and John Mozeliak eras, the two General Managers that have helmed player procurement since 1995. Collecting that data allowed me to create today’s graph, which illustrates how much value was provided to the organization each season by players acquired via three primary means- draft, trade, and free agency. To show value, I’ve used Baseball Reference’s WAR statistic- Wins Above Replacement, explained here. Basically, a player’s WAR is the number of wins he provides to his team over and beyond what a readily available replacement player could be expected to provide.

Two things instantly become recognizable when looking at the graph. First and foremost, you can see a massive organizational shift towards draft and development during the Mozeliak era. While that’s hardly news for most Cardinals fans or even most hardcore baseball fans, it’s interesting to see the degree to which this strategy is bearing fruit. Second, it verifies Walt Jocketty’s reputation as a shrewd trader, at least during the organization’s peak under his helm (2000-2005).

As always, click on the image for the full resolution.



Filed under Baseball

3 responses to “Graph: St. Louis Cardinals: WAR by Acquisition Type (1995-2013)

  1. Very interesting. I think they’ve done amazing work with developing young talent during the past few years. Even so, i do feel like they could do a little better via free agency. Jocketty was in the “win now” camp, which earned big results, and I don’t want to see them trade away young talent. A little more balance might help. Even so, the great results show that they’re on the right track for sure.

    • It seems like the big strategy is to invest big in a core (Yadi, Holliday, Waino), take a measured risk or two in free agency (first Berkman, then Beltran, now Peralta), and then surround it with homegrown talent. It’s a great plan as long as you’re developing the way they are. But if it ever cools off (and I don’t see how it won’t, if only because they’ve been so amazing developing guys the last few years), they’re going to have to do something else.

  2. Pingback: Revolution in the Blink of an Eye: The St. Louis Cardinals Since 1995 |

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s